Remnant caved and produced the documents on September 22, 2008. After examining them we believed that those documents provided us a basis for counterclaims against the attorneys, since they knew or should have known that the case was frivolous from the get go. They then dropped the case like a hot potato, trying to get the court to order us to surrender those documents to them, when there was no legal reason why we should have to. We therefore appealed.